The unveiling of Australia’s Test squad for the upcoming series against Pakistan has stirred controversy, primarily centered around the inclusion of David Warner. Former Australian cricket star Mitchell Johnson expressed disapproval of Warner’s participation, condemning the left-handed opener and reigniting discussions about the infamous ball-tampering scandal. Johnson, critical of Warner, asserted that the southpaw doesn’t merit a “hero’s sendoff,” particularly considering the Pakistan series potentially marking his farewell.

Adding fuel to the fire, Johnson directed his criticism towards Australia’s chief selector, George Bailey, accusing him of choosing Warner despite the latter’s lackluster Test performance. Reflecting on Bailey’s previous stance during Tim Paine’s departure over the sexting controversy, Johnson raised questions about Bailey’s proximity to players, suggesting it might impact selection decisions.

In response to Johnson’s comments, Bailey expressed concern for the former cricketer’s well-being and defended his approach as a selector. Bailey emphasized the importance of being aware of players’ situations and team plans, challenging the notion that distance and unawareness could be more beneficial.

Despite Warner’s impressive Test record—participating in 109 matches, amassing 8487 runs at an average of 44.33, with 25 centuries and 36 half-centuries—his recent Test average since 2020 has declined to 31.79. Bailey, however, maintains Warner’s status as one of Australia’s premier Test players.

Bailey defended Warner’s selection for the first Test against Pakistan, emphasizing the critical nature of each game in the World Test Championship. He acknowledged the team’s focus on choosing the best eleven players and highlighted Warner’s role in achieving success.

Admitting the ongoing search for Warner’s successor, Bailey acknowledged the challenge of replacing a player of Warner’s caliber. He underscored the unique ability Warner possesses to put the opposition under pressure, expressing the need to carefully consider the right fit post-Warner.

In drawing parallels to the challenges faced after Shane Warne’s retirement, Bailey cautioned against attempting to replicate a player’s role too quickly. Recognizing Warner’s extended and dominant role as an opener, Bailey emphasized the importance of ensuring the right fit for the team post-Warner.